Friday, March 18, 2011

Gotta Love the Republicans - Medicare madness

Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
posted at 03/17/2012 09:47:08 PM EDT
I think Dana Milbank is absolutely right......the party leaders wouldn't be caught saying this, but if Republicans gained both the WH and congress, the conservatives wanting to do this couldn't be stopped. They really are this crazy.

‘Mediscare,’ Republican style

Are Republicans ready to be trusted with the reins of power?
If you’re thinking of answering this in the affirmative, you might want to pause long enough to learn what transpired on the third floor of the Capitol on Thursday. There, four prominent Republican lawmakers announced their proposal to abolish Medicare — “sunset” was their pseudo-verb — even for those currently on the program or nearing retirement.
In Medicare’s place would be a private plan that would raise the eligibility age and shift trillions of dollars worth of health-care coverage from the government to the elderly. “This will be the new Medicare,” Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), the proposal’s author, announced.
For years, Republicans have insisted that they would not end Medicare as we know it and that any changes to the program would not affect those in or near retirement. In the span of 20 minutes Thursday, they jettisoned both promises.
He’s right about that. Don’t expect Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, Mitch McConnell or John Boehner to take up the cry; the party leadership isn’t about to line up for abolishing the popular entitlement program. The real question is whether party leaders would be able to repel this conservative movement to end Medicare if Republicans gain control of the White House and Congress, where conservatives already dominate the GOP caucuses.
The end-Medicare sponsors are key figures: DeMint is the godfather of the Tea Party, and he was joined by Paul and Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), two conservative rising stars. Completing the foursome was Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), an influential thinker. Two other Republican senators, Richard Burr of North Carolina and Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, have introduced a somewhat related plan to deal with Medicare, and Rep. Paul Ryan’s House Republican budget would also privatize Medicare, though on a slower timetable.
But DeMint and his colleagues think the time to end Medicare is now — with a cold-turkey conversion to a private program, effective in 2014. “I think if Americans actually find out the truth about what we’re doing, it will be a very big positive for Republicans in the fall,” DeMint forecast.
  • 1
  • 2
REPUBLICANS: END MEDICARE BY 2014
    • LITI8R
    • First Post: 9/29/2010
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 7298
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:30:16 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by runner50
    Thinkprogress is a tabloid media source.  Maybe you should watch more FOX.  You'r ebeing duped.
    – CLAIM 4 FROM PAWLENTY: Medicare is not financially solvent. FACT: Medicare is fully solvent until 2024. After 2024, the hospital fund will still be able to meet “90 percent” of its commitments.
    _____________________________
    Funds Running Out Faster Than Expected for Social Security and Medicare Programs

    Bad Economy Means Medicare Will Run Out Of Cash Sooner

    Social Security and Medicare to run short sooner than expected


    Trustees' Report: Medicare To Run Out Of Funds



    • LITI8R
    • First Post: 9/29/2010
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 7298
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:20:51 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by IMCONCERNED
    "America's Seniors must make sure OBAMA IS A ONE TERM PRESIDENT." 
    Obama has caused SO MUCH damage to our country since he took office.  I fear that whether he's re-elected or not will have little effect on this spiralling economy and structure as we know it.
    BUT....I don't give up easily.  I'm going to support Republicans in any way that I can to assure Obama is OUT.

    • Quackers
    • First Post: 9/4/2008
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 17048
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:20:06 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by IMCONCERNED
    You approve of Obama appointing Dr Berwick, health care rationing supporter to head Medicare.

    Wow, your first two sentences are pants on fire wrong. Dr. Berwick's statement about "rationing" healthcare was taken out of context and grossly distorted by lying through their teeth conservatives. Why? Because he is the nation's top cost cutting expert and would have been very good in his role of reducing medical costs.....can't have that, now can we? His statement about rationing was made in the context of being smart and putting our money in treatments that are proven to work best...........scary stuff, eh? Btw, I know this because I took the time to read the transcript where he talked about "rationing" instead of mindlessly taking the word of Faux News that he was just like Dr. Kevorkian.
    • runner50
    • First Post: 6/25/2010
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 4032
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:19:55 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by IMCONCERNED
    I knew somone would throw out the boring "Obama and the Democrats defunding $500 Billion from Medicare" myth. OK, here it is again, along with other  intentional distortions of the facts from the Republicans and Tea Party, to promote fear mongering and health care scare tactics.
    – CLAIM 1 FROM BACHMANN: The Congressional Budget Office said the Affordable Care Act will kill 800,000 jobs. FACT: The CBO actually found that some people would leave the workforce or work less because they can find affordable health coverage elsewhere. This is a reduction in the supply of labor, not a reduction in the supply of jobs.
    – CLAIM 2 FROM BACHMANN: Obamacare took $500 billion out of Medicare, shifted it to build a new entitlement for young people. FACT: The health law does not cut the current Medicare budget; it slows the growth in the program by removing $500 billion from future spending over the next 10 years. The cuts help stabilize Medicare by eliminating overpayments and slowly phasing in payment adjustments that encourage greater efficiency. As a result, the law extends the life of the Medicare trust fund by nine years and allows seniors to retain all of their guaranteed Medicare benefits.
    – CLAIM 3 FROM ROMNEY: I would issue an executive order paving the way for Obamacare waivers to all 50 states. FACT: The executive branch and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) don’t have the authority to grant blanket waivers — those powers are reserved for Congress.
    – CLAIM 4 FROM PAWLENTY: Medicare is not financially solvent. FACT: Medicare is fully solvent until 2024. After 2024, the hospital fund will still be able to meet “90 percent” of its commitments.
    – CLAIM 5 FROM SANTORUM: Paul Ryan’s Medicare plan is “identical to what seniors already have” — Medicare Part D. FACT: It’s not. The government pays 74 percent of costs in Medicare Part D and grows that support at the rate of program costs. “Ryan’s plan covers about a third of beneficiary costs, and that support grows at the rate of inflation — so much more slowly than the rest of the program, or than Medicare Part D.”
    – CLAIM 6 FROM SANTORUM: The Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) will ration care to seniors beginning in 2014. FACT: The IPAB kicks in if health care spending goes beyond a certain threshold and is statutorily prohibited from rationing benefits or increasing co-pays. In fact, Paul Ryan even supported a more aggressive IPAB-type reform in 2009. 
    • LITI8R
    • First Post: 9/29/2010
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 7298
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:19:42 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by alexpinca
    "BUT AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED, IF SENIORS SUPPORT THESE B***ARDS, THEY DESERVED WHAT THEY GET!"
    I'll be voting REPUBLICAN!  Medicare will END in just a few years IF YOU DON'T.
    Republican's want to SAVE Medicare.  Obama is doing NOTHING to secure your future and it's about time you WAKE UP.  
    This thread in itself shows how duped some are here by Obama's TALK.  No ACTION....No PLAN....just TALK.
    To blame the Republican's for the demise of Medicare is just plain STUPID.  Do the math.......!  
    If you don't vote Republican you can kiss Medicare good-bye.  
    • Quackers
    • First Post: 9/4/2008
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 17048
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 10:20:40 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by IMCONCERNED
    You approve of Obama and the Democrats defunding $500 Billion from Medicare to fund Obamacare.

    They did not. Have you received a notice yet of benefit cuts? Thought you didn't. LOL Most of the "cuts" come from cutting subsidies to Medicare Advantage, the private Medicare policies that Republicans promised could deliver Medicare cheaper than the government could. Turns out they spend $1.15 to Medicare's $1.
    • IMCONCERNED
    • First Post: 8/16/2009
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 1364
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 09:10:55 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by alexpinca
    You approve of Obama and the Democrats defunding $500 Billion from Medicare to fund Obamacare.  You approve of Obama appointing Dr Berwick, health care rationing supporter to head Medicare.  You support Obama's creation of the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) that was created with the passage of the  health care law represents the worst of health care reform. IPAB would allow an unelected board to singularly enact spending cuts in the Medicare program through binding recommendations to reduce Medicare spending. This is the NEW DEMOCRATC MEDICARE.  America's Seniors most make sure OBAMA IS A ONE TERM PRESIDENT. 
    • alexpinca
    • First Post: 5/29/2011
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 701
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 04:00:23 AM EDT
    I don't think it is an understatement to say that the changes proposed by the right wing extremists will ensure either death or poverty of millions of seniors...BUT AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED, IF SENIORS SUPPORT THESE B***ARDS, THEY DESERVED WHAT THEY GET!
    • Quackers
    • First Post: 9/4/2008
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 17048
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 04:00:19 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by runner50
    Why don't we make sure this doesn't even have a chance of happening, SENIORS, by endingREPUBLICANS this year, and 2014. Throw their pasty back ends out. Get out there andVOTE!"

    I intend to do my part. I'm waiting for someone to jump in and spin it that they don't really mean to end it.
    • runner50
    • First Post: 6/25/2010
    • Last Post: 3/18/2012
    • Total Posts: 4032
    RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/18/2012 02:34:45 AM EDT
    In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by Quackers
    Why don't we make sure this doesn't even have a chance of happening, SENIORS, by endingREPUBLICANS this year, and 2014. Throw their pasty back ends out. Get out there andVOTE!"




    Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
    posted at 03/17/2012 09:47:08 PM EDT
    I think Dana Milbank is absolutely right......the party leaders wouldn't be caught saying this, but if Republicans gained both the WH and congress, the conservatives wanting to do this couldn't be stopped. They really are this crazy.

    ‘Mediscare,’ Republican style

    Are Republicans ready to be trusted with the reins of power?
    If you’re thinking of answering this in the affirmative, you might want to pause long enough to learn what transpired on the third floor of the Capitol on Thursday. There, four prominent Republican lawmakers announced their proposal to abolish Medicare — “sunset” was their pseudo-verb — even for those currently on the program or nearing retirement.
    In Medicare’s place would be a private plan that would raise the eligibility age and shift trillions of dollars worth of health-care coverage from the government to the elderly. “This will be the new Medicare,” Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), the proposal’s author, announced.
    For years, Republicans have insisted that they would not end Medicare as we know it and that any changes to the program would not affect those in or near retirement. In the span of 20 minutes Thursday, they jettisoned both promises.
    He’s right about that. Don’t expect Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, Mitch McConnell or John Boehner to take up the cry; the party leadership isn’t about to line up for abolishing the popular entitlement program. The real question is whether party leaders would be able to repel this conservative movement to end Medicare if Republicans gain control of the White House and Congress, where conservatives already dominate the GOP caucuses.
    The end-Medicare sponsors are key figures: DeMint is the godfather of the Tea Party, and he was joined by Paul and Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), two conservative rising stars. Completing the foursome was Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), an influential thinker. Two other Republican senators, Richard Burr of North Carolina and Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, have introduced a somewhat related plan to deal with Medicare, and Rep. Paul Ryan’s House Republican budget would also privatize Medicare, though on a slower timetable.
    But DeMint and his colleagues think the time to end Medicare is now — with a cold-turkey conversion to a private program, effective in 2014. “I think if Americans actually find out the truth about what we’re doing, it will be a very big positive for Republicans in the fall,” DeMint forecast.
    • 1
    • 2
    REPUBLICANS: END MEDICARE BY 2014
      • runner50
      • First Post: 6/25/2010
      • Last Post: 3/18/2012
      • Total Posts: 4032
      RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/18/2012 02:34:45 AM EDT
      In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by Quackers
      Why don't we make sure this doesn't even have a chance of happening, SENIORS, by endingREPUBLICANS this year, and 2014. Throw their pasty back ends out. Get out there andVOTE!"
      • Quackers
      • First Post: 9/4/2008
      • Last Post: 3/18/2012
      • Total Posts: 17049
      RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/17/2012 11:42:58 PM EDT
      In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by sunnyside411
      Well sourced story and pretty much tells it like it is.

      Exactly. What they leave out is that as well as wanting to do this, they also are promising to get rid of the ACA. Without the ACA there is no law saying insurers can't turn down people with preexisting conditions...............so where does that leave sick seniors?
      • sunnyside411
      • First Post: 7/5/2011
      • Last Post: 3/17/2012
      • Total Posts: 5968
      RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/17/2012 10:52:16 PM EDT
      In Response to Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by Quackers
      Well sourced story and pretty much tells it like it is.
      • Quackers
      • First Post: 9/4/2008
      • Last Post: 3/18/2012
      • Total Posts: 17049
      RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/17/2012 10:37:29 PM EDT
      In Response to RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by xrepub
      The repugs have been trying to end Medicare and SS since before they were enacted. They will always try to do it even while claiming they are not.


      Exactly. They never change. No Medicare to trash back then, but here's what FDR said about Republicans. Sound familiar? LOL


      "Let me warn you and let me warn the Nation against the smooth evasion which says, “Of course we believe all these things; we believe in social security; we believe in work for the unemployed; we believe in saving homes. Cross our hearts and hope to die, we believe in all these things; but we do not like the way the present Administration is doing them. Just turn them over to us. We will do all of them- we will do more of them we will do them better; and, most important of all, the doing of them will not cost anybody anything.”
      But, my friends, these evaders are banking too heavily on the shortness of our memories. No one will forget that they had their golden opportunity—twelve long years of it.
      Remember, too, that the first essential of doing a job well is to want to see the job done. Make no mistake about this: the Republican leadership today is not against the way we have done the job. The Republican leadership is against the job’s being done."

      • xrepub
      • First Post: 1/23/2009
      • Last Post: 3/17/2012
      • Total Posts: 3537
      RE: Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/17/2012 10:03:20 PM EDT
      In Response to Republicans: End Medicare by 2014 by Quackers
      The repugs have been trying to end Medicare and SS since before they were enacted. They will always try to do it even while claiming they are not.

      • Quackers
      • First Post: 9/4/2008
      • Last Post: 3/18/2012
      • Total Posts: 17049
      Republicans: End Medicare by 2014
      posted at 03/17/2012 09:47:08 PM EDT
      I think Dana Milbank is absolutely right......the party leaders wouldn't be caught saying this, but if Republicans gained both the WH and congress, the conservatives wanting to do this couldn't be stopped. They really are this crazy.

      ‘Mediscare,’ Republican style

      Are Republicans ready to be trusted with the reins of power?
      If you’re thinking of answering this in the affirmative, you might want to pause long enough to learn what transpired on the third floor of the Capitol on Thursday. There, four prominent Republican lawmakers announced their proposal to abolish Medicare — “sunset” was their pseudo-verb — even for those currently on the program or nearing retirement.
      In Medicare’s place would be a private plan that would raise the eligibility age and shift trillions of dollars worth of health-care coverage from the government to the elderly. “This will be the new Medicare,” Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), the proposal’s author, announced.
      For years, Republicans have insisted that they would not end Medicare as we know it and that any changes to the program would not affect those in or near retirement. In the span of 20 minutes Thursday, they jettisoned both promises.
      He’s right about that. Don’t expect Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, Mitch McConnell or John Boehner to take up the cry; the party leadership isn’t about to line up for abolishing the popular entitlement program. The real question is whether party leaders would be able to repel this conservative movement to end Medicare if Republicans gain control of the White House and Congress, where conservatives already dominate the GOP caucuses.
      The end-Medicare sponsors are key figures: DeMint is the godfather of the Tea Party, and he was joined by Paul and Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), two conservative rising stars. Completing the foursome was Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), an influential thinker. Two other Republican senators, Richard Burr of North Carolina and Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, have introduced a somewhat related plan to deal with Medicare, and Rep. Paul Ryan’s House Republican budget would also privatize Medicare, though on a slower timetable.
      But DeMint and his colleagues think the time to end Medicare is now — with a cold-turkey conversion to a private program, effective in 2014. “I think if Americans actually find out the truth about what we’re doing, it will be a very big positive for Republicans in the fall,” DeMint forecast.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Sarah Palin --- Does America need a Dumb Female Joker to lead the Country???

Craziest Sarah Palin Quotes of All Time

Sarah Palin Insane-O-Matic Quote Generator

''Dr. Laura: don't retreat...reload!''

—a Tweeted message from Sarah Palin in defense of radio talker Laura Schlessinger who took heat for a racially charged rant at a female African-American caller in which Schlessinger repeatedly used the word ''nigger.'
'

''I'm not politically correct. I am not one to be a word police.''

—Sarah Palin, Fox interview with Chris Wallace Feb. 7 , 2010

''As for that VP talk all the time, I'll tell you, I still can't answer that question until somebody answers for me what is it exactly that the VP does every day?''





—Sarah Palin, interview with CNBC's 'Kudlow & Co', July 2008

''We may have another Oprah on our hands. Since leaving her job as the governor of Alaska, Sarah Palin has made more than $12 million. That is a lot of money for someone who can't say words that end in 'g.''' —Jimmy Kimmel


How Republicans expect to win your votes....
1. Convince the Public That Government is Bad
The only entity that stands between corporate domination of the people of the United States and a legitimate democracy…is our government.  The consistent, decades-long campaign by Republicans to attack our government as “evil” and “bad” (even when they’ve been in control of all branches!) has an end game. Destroy the public’s power by creating both distrust and apathy towards the government that protects it. That reduces support and voter turnout which makes buying candidates and votes (through campaign ads and propaganda) far easier. It also does another very important thing, it puts the public in a position to cheer the weakening of their own government.
After all, such a corrupt and inept behemoth that does nothing right except take our money from us, should be smothered in its crib as the Republicans say, right?
2. Convince The Public That Only By Cutting Spending on Those Who Aren’t Wealthy,  We Will All Be Wealthier.
The declarations by Republicans that around 50% of the nation doesn’t even pay income tax and the wealthy pay so much of it, the endless moaning about how high the corporate tax rates are in the US, the attacks on the unemployed as lazy, on teachers and all other public employees as greedy, on the elderly as eating up too much of our money through Medicare and Social Security and on and on while always saying that the wealthy and corporations that hold the lion’s share of wealth in this nation should have more.
They have all their ridiculous and unsubstantiated, even disproven talking points which have been hammered into the public consciousness such as, trickle down, calling the wealthy Plutocracy “Job Creators” (it does have a better ring than “Fascist Overlords”), insisting that tax cuts for the wealthy create jobs as does getting rid of government regulation and oversight (despite history proving the opposite). It’s a well thought out line of propaganda which is in fact saying, “Give those who are above you more of your wealth and labor and one day, it will all come back to you and you’ll be a millionaire too!”
Americans are terribly gullible. Ask anyone who bought a ticket to see Charlie Sheen perform live. They want so desperately to believe that they will indeed be millionaires one day,  in fact, they buy lottery tickets that have a 1 in 195,249,054 chance of winning a jackpot (these are the actual odds of the Powerball lottery, meaning, if everyone in America, men, women and children, bought lottery tickets in Powerball…only one person out of the entire population of the United States is likely to win…but it could be you so buy your ticket now!).
Americans are still clapping for Tinkerbell as adults and those who are the most powerful and cynical, those who have invested billions over time in marketing to understand how best to manipulate Americans into buying products and politicians, know this and use this against them. This is how such a ridiculous proposition, that giving tax breaks to billionaire corporations who pay $0 in taxes, who have sent millions of jobs out of the country, who force those remaining employees to do twice as much work as they used to without their pay increasing, will give the other 99.5% of Americans all the wealth and happiness they’re looking for. Now, all of this is  incorporated into the budgeting that the Republicans are doing under the guise of “being more fiscally responsible”.  The destruction of the middle class and destroying the quality of life for a majority of the nation, in order to increase the wealth of the wealthy, is apparently “fiscally responsible”.
What I think the people of the United States should do is stand up to demand both fiscal and moral responsibility. We should demand that if the poor and middle class are going to be forced to sacrifice profoundly to put the nation on a solid economic footing, it’s high time for the wealthy to make just as severe a sacrifice. We have participated in this farce long enough, accepting that there is only one side to the coin, only the side of cutting expenses and not the side of increasing revenue.
There is a great deal of hardship that the cuts in the 2011 budget will impose on many Americans but those making $1 million dollars or more each year won’t experience any of that. What sacrifice is being asked of them? We simply can’t allow  this Orwellian bullshit to go on without being called out for what it is. No, the wealthier getting wealthier does not make the poor wealthier or even the middle class. It just makes the wealthy wealthier and they are doing so by looting our taxes and cutting the services and safety nets we need. This makes no sense and though the loons in the Tea Party are oblivious to how they’re being used, average Americans should be urged to recognize this.
Which brings me to the budget negotiations ahead for 2012. Pres. Obama and the Dems have made a lot of compromises to get this 2011 budget passed, some were very severe. However, IMO, instead of focusing on what was done, those who care about their fellow Americans and the future of their nation should tell our President and Congress members, “Okay, now we can say we have made painful sacrifices for millions of Americans who are not well off. Now we need to stand tough on raising revenues from those who are very well off in a way that is just as painful to them.”
Either the point of all of this is for ALL of us in this nation to sacrifice for the betterment of the whole or it is for those who are not wealthy to sacrifice to keep those that are wealthy in the lifestyle to which they have come accustomed and ask if they want a foot massage and their grapes peeled.
I think that Pres. Obama and the Dems in Congress have the high ground now to demand tax increases and closed loopholes for the wealthy, to save this nation. I think that needs to be their strategy now. The Republican’s desire to kill Medicare won’t be permitted but the other severe cuts the Republicans have in mind for 99% of the nation can’t be permitted either. Yes, the Republicans will refuse to vote for tax increases but the sky won’t fall if the 2012 budget isn’t passed this year (we just passed the budget for this year with nearly half of it already gone by!).
If this means they’re going to threaten to vote against raising the debt ceiling, so be it. That will be solely on their heads then if the US and world economy worsen because it isn’t raised. The bottom line is, if we decide to go along with the Republicans on slowly poisoning our nation to death because if we don’t, they’re threatening to push it off a cliff, what’s the difference in the end? Either way we’re dead. The only way we survive is to push them into a corner and force them to either concede or ultimately expose themselves beyond any doubt as the danger they are to the nation and the world and how unfit they are to hold power.
With the fear of the Repubs blocking the increase of the debt ceiling assuaged, Obama and the Dems can turn to them and say, “Make my day.” Look how the Repubs buckled at the prospect of the government shutdown, they knew it would destroy them in 2012. Well…how would it look to them to have the world economy tanking because of them and them alone?  I don’t think they’ll do it. Do they really believe that they could win in 2012 after causing the global economy to be thrown into turmoil? And even if they did, the rest of us rational folk know that 2012 would become a Dem landslide if that happened and then Obama and a Dem Congress could have to opportunity to reverse damage done in the previous two years by the Repubs.
The only way to deal with a bully is through strength. The Repubs got to have this recent budget fight on their own terms and they are expecting the next ones to be that way too. What Obama and the Dems should do is deny them this, stand up to them and say, “You want the majority of Americans to take another massive hit? No, we demand the wealthy take their turn sacrificing now.”
Face off with them on this issue, fighting for 99% of Americans and let the Repubs fight for the 1%. Define them and the election in 2012 now, this is about oppressing and taking from the American people to make the wealthy wealthier and more powerful or it’s about the wealthy making just as profound a sacrifice as the majority of the nation to save its future.
In other words, we’ve had enough of digging ditches under our feet to make the economy around us look bigger. Instead, it’s time to raise up the people and the economy with them.

“What a load of crappola. Worried by a Republican digging ? Who cares.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Intelligent Design: Losing the Catholics and quite likely the republicans too...

Intelligent Design: Losing the Catholics


This has not been a good year for the Discovery Institute. I'm sure book sales to their core creationist audience of Biblical literalists are steady. And, as Barbara Forrest has shown, they're hoping the Louisiana State Education Act, which is directly based on their own template for state public education policy, allows Fundamentalists in at least one state to disallow biology science textbooks that teach evolution.
But that's not the same thing as having one of your Institute Fellows get a paper published in Nature. Or Cell. Or Science. It's not the same thing as celebrating a grant from the NSF to pursue some promising research.
The Discovery Institute has from its beginning claimed it would in short order get actual scientists to consider intelligent design as a viable scientific theory, by publishing peer-reviewed articles in the leading science journals.
But they've failed. And no matter how much cheering the Institute Fellows get from friendly audiences at Bible schools and church socials, the reality is: this was not the way things were supposed to turn out.
And now, they're losing the Catholics.
This past year, prominent Catholic conservative intellectuals at once ID-friendly magazines and web sites, started to break their silence about the vapidity of intelligent design.
First, Edward Feser, professor of philosophy at Pasadena College, began posting a series of essays showing up the hollow philosophical shell at the heart of intelligent design. Feser's main point is that, at least for Catholics, ID is hopelessly devoid of solid metaphysical grounding:
The problems are twofold. First, both Paleyan "design arguments" and ID theory take for granted an essentially mechanistic conception of the natural world. What this means is that they deny the existence of the sort of immanent teleology or final causality affirmed by the Aristotelian-Thomistic-Scholastic tradition, and instead regard all teleology as imposed, "artificially" as it were, from outside.
Feser's posts are detailed, well-researched, and an excellent resource for any Christian parent confused by the contradictory claims of ID proponents.
Next, University of Delaware physicist Stephen M. Barr decided it was time to be frank: intelligent design, he wrote in First Things, has been a disaster:
What has the intelligent design movement achieved? As science, nothing. The goal of science is to increase our understanding of the natural world, and there is not a single phenomenon that we understand better today or are likely to understand better in the future through the efforts of ID theorists. If we are to look for ID achievements, then, it must be in the realm of natural theology. And there, I think, the movement must be judged not only a failure, but a debacle.
There have, of course, been weak attempts by Discovery Institute flaks to claim Aquinas as an ally in support of their argument for design; indeed some claim that Aquinas' Fifth Argument is the classic argument for design. But this does not stand up to scrutiny, as philosopher-blogger Brandon Watson has pointed out:
The problem is that the Fifth Way is not actually a design argument. The phrase translated by 'designedly' here is actually ex intentione; but ex intentione does not signify design but orientation. The Fifth Way is actually an argument not from design but from the fact that there's any causation at all. On Aquinas's scholastic adaptation of Aristotle, the end or final cause is what selects the effect for the efficient cause -- in other words, it is what answers the question, "Why does this cause produce this effect rather than some other effect?" The disposition of the cause to the end is its intentio. The word is associated in the medieval imagination with archery: the aim of the arrow is its intentio. So the argument of the Fifth Way is roughly that because nonintelligent things act regularly in order to achieve an end, they must achieve their end not a casu, by chance, but ex intentione, by being disposed to it. But things not capable of determining their own ends have to be, in the end, disposed to them by things capable of determining ends, namely, intelligences. So what is supposed to be at stake in this argument is not design but any sort of causation that is not due to deliberate self-determination; what's being examined is the very possibility of bodies having effects at all. This is perfectly general; final causes are for Aquinas the explanation for the fact that efficient causation occurs at all.
The 13th century Dominican theologian would have been as puzzled by intelligent design proponents as today's Dominican biologists are.
Father Nicanor Austriaco, a biologist and Dominican who has his own lab at Providence College, published a paper in 2003 called In Defense of Double Agency in Evolution: A Response to Five Modern Critics (not available online, alas) in the Rome-based Catholic journal, Angelicum, showing just how comprehensively evolution can be accommodated in a true Catholic philosophical and theological tradition.
For Austriaco, the tradition is clear. "When double agency is cast within the classical framework of Western theism especially as it was articulated by St. Thomas Aquinas," he wrote, "it remains a coherent and fruitful theological explanation for divine action in an evolving world." No watchmaker in the sky is required in the simplistic sense that ID proponents insist is the only explanation standing ... between Christian children and certain atheism.
"When we talk about evolution," Austriaco told me in a recent interview, "most people think that to affirm that evolution is a contingent process, is to necessarily exclude divine providence." But this is simply not the case, he argues. "The irony about the intelligent design debate today, is that the intelligent design proponents, like the Darwinists, presuppose an opposition between chance and design. They necessitate an opposition between chance and design. If it's design, it cannot be chance. If it's chance, it cannot be design. There is no option -- and there are philosophical reasons why the moderns can't come up with this -- there is no option, no one thinks about the possibility of talking about God's design working through chance, through contingency."
Needless to say, Catholics like Fr. Austriaco, Professors Feser and Barr, are not the kind of Christians whose views are welcome at the Discovery Institute. [It goes without saying that Brown biology professor Kenneth Miller might as well be Public Enemy No. 1.]
So, all is not well in Seattle. For Christians who support solid science education, that's something to celebrate. The more the vapid arguments of the Discovery Institute are exposed, the smaller and smaller their audience will become.
 
 
 
Follow John Farrell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JohnWFarrell

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Tea Baggers and Violence....



My heart breaks for Gabby Giffords....



When Gabby Giffords was shot everyone noticed. It was all over the news, I saw it in my friends' Facebook statuses, it was part of everyone's conversations. Today's stories about her was barely an "also happened" but the truth is today, as she leaves the hospital and heads for rehab, is when her fight really begins. For the last two weeks everyone around the country fought with her, now she begins the much harder part of her journey, battling on her own to regain her life.



Tea Party Forging Links With Violent

Tea Party Getting Violent? 10 House Dems Report Threats, Vandalism

WASHINGTON (CBS/AP) Political pundits knew health care reform was going to upset critics and the "tea party" contingent, but they probably didn't expect things to get violent.
The Democratic leadership in Congress is decrying recent "acts of violence" against 10 House Democrats and one Republican, including one report of a cut gas line at the house of the brother of one member of Congress.
The most recent report came from US Rep. Harry Mitchell, AZ, whose spokesman, Adam Bozzi, said in a statement that the congressman received physical threats, including threats on his life, both before and after a vote on health care reform.
A brick was thrown through the window of the district office of Democratic Congresswoman Louise Slaughter in Niagara Falls, in upstate New York, while Bart Stupak, the conservative Democrat whose deal with the White House on abortion funding curbs provided the crucial last few votes for passage of the bill, reported getting calls from people wishing that he "bleed, get cancer and die."
Representative James Clyburn, the highest ranking black lawmaker, said he received a fax with an image of a noose.
Even the families of representatives aren't immune to the backlash, apparently. The Albemarle County Fire Marshal's Office and the FBI have concluded, in a joint statement, that a severed gas line outside of the house of Rep. Tom Perriello's (D-Va.) brother was "an act of vandalism." Perriello supported the overhaul measure and an activist involved in the "tea party" movement reportedly posted the brother's address on an internet forum - apparently thinking it was the congressman's - and urged angry opponents to pay him a visit.
House Republican Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, says he knows that people are angry but denounced the disturbing trend, saying, "Threats and violence should not be part of a political debate." 

http://nocureforthat.files.wordpress.com/2010/10/s-tea-party-signs-large.jpg 
1. White powder and swastikas were mailed to Rep. Grijalva. On October 21, an envelope containing “a plastic bag of white powder and two pieces of paper with swastikas written on them” was reportedly mailed to Rep. Raul Grijalva’s (D-AZ) campaign office. The powder was determined to be non-toxic.

2. Byron Williams set out to kill people at Tides Foundation and ACLU. On July 18, Byron Williams was stopped by California Highway Patrol and engaged in a shootout with law enforcement. He later said he planned to murder individuals at the Tides Foundation and ACLU. His mother said he was angry about “Congress railroading through all these left-wing agenda items.” As reporter John Hamilton documented, Williams said he saw Fox News’ Glenn Beck as “a schoolteacher” and that “it was the things [Beck] exposed that blew my mind.” Indeed, the gunman, Byron Williams, was driven by belief in conspiracy theories that have been pushed by Beck and other members of the right-wing media.
3. AZ federal judge threatened, Grijalva office fired on after ruling on AZ immigration law. Politico reported in July:
Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-Ariz.) said in a statement he shut down his Yuma district office after staff members discovered a bullet had shattered a window there Thursday. And authorities said U.S. Judge Susan Bolton received hundreds of threats at her downtown Phoenix court offices after issuing the injunction, according to news reports.
4. Phoenix man indicted for alleged murder threats against Grijalva and his aides. The Yuma Sun reported on June 14 that a Phoenix man was indicted on federal charges for “allegedly threatening to kill U.S. Rep. Raul Grijalva in late April, over Grijalva’s opposition to the state’s new immigration law.” The article added: “Prosecutors say Haynes is accused of calling Grijalva’s office in Tucson twice on April 23 and threatening to ‘come down there and blow the brains out’ of Grijalva and his employees.”
5. Man arrested for allegedly threatening to kill Sen. Patty Murray. Politico reported on April 6:
Charles Alan Wilson, 64, was arrested at his home in central Washington after he allegedly called Murray’s office on numerous occasions over the last few weeks saying that she “had a target on her back, ” and “I want to [expletive] kill you,” according to court documents. The alleged phone calls stretched over almost two weeks and were said to be in relation to Murray’s vote to pass health care overhaul legislation.
Wilson, who was arrested in Selah, Wash., also allegedly told undercover FBI agents that he carries a concealed firearm with a permit, and said he was “extremely angry” with the passage of health care legislation, according to the news release. If convicted, Wilson could face up to 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine.
6. Members of right-wing militia group arrested for allegedly plotting overthrow of the U.S. government. Nine members of the “Hutaree militia” were arrested in March and charged with plotting a violent uprising against the U.S. government, a plot that was to begin with an attack on law enforcement personnel. The Southern Poverty Law Center has called the Hutaree militia as a member of the radical right-wing patriot movement.
7. AP: Man arrested for allegedly making threatening phone calls to Pelosi. The AP reported that in the days after the vote on the health care reform bill, “The FBI arrested a California man Wednesday for allegedly making threatening phone calls to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi.”
8. Threats made against Rep. Betsy Markey. A Denver television station reported that Rep. Betsy Markey’s (D-CO) chief of staff “said the calls came on Saturday before the House cast its final vote on health care reform. She said in the first, the caller said to one of Markey’s staff members, ‘better hope I don’t run into you in a dark alley with a knife, a club or a gun.’ In another instance, a caller said something like ‘better tell your boss that she better be careful when she comes back here to Colorado.’”
9. Gas line outside the house of the brother of Rep. Tom Perriello was cut. Rep. Tom Perriello’s (D-VA) brother’s address was erroneously posted online by a Tea Party blogger who invited activists to descend on the house. In March, a gas line outside the brother’s house was cut.
10. Threats made against Rep. Stupak after he voted for final version of health care bill. Rep. Bart Stupak (D-MI) was the target of threatening faxes and phone calls, includingdeath threats. Some of the faxes included “racial epithets used in reference to President Obama,” according to CBS News.
11. Picture of a noose faxed to Rep. Clyburn. Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC), the Majority Whip, said in a March interview on CNN that his office had received a fax of a noose after he voted in favor of the health care reform bill.
12. Brick thrown at Democratic county headquarters in Rochester, NY. New York Daily News reported on March 22 that, after the House health care vote, a “brick, to which a piece of paper bearing the message “Extremism is defense of liberty is no vice” was attached with a rubber band” was thrown through the headquarters of the Democratic county headquarters in Rochester, New York.
13. Rep. Slaughter threatened with brick and “snipers.” CNN reported on March 24: “Rep. Louise Slaughter, D-New York, said her Niagara Falls district office had a brick thrown through one of its windows and a message that referred to ‘snipers’ was left on one of her campaign offices.”
14. Rep. Giffords’ office window shattered. CNN reported that in March, “a glass panel at the Tucson office of U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, D-Arizona, was shattered, spokesman C.J. Karamargin said. It wasn’t clear how the window was shattered, but visitors have to go through a gated courtyard to enter the office, and staffers suspect someone may have shot a pellet gun at the glass, he said.”
15. White powder mailed to Rep. Weiner with “drop dead” message. NBC News reported on March 26:
Authorities are investigating a package with white powder and an angry letter that referenced the health care legislation that was sent to Congressman Weiner’s Kew Gardens office today.
The letter said the Congressman should “drop dead” and complained about the historic health care legislation passed by Congress this week.
Preliminary field tests showed the white powder was harmless.
16. Rep. Driehaus threatened and right-wing blogger publishes his home address. Politico reported on March 24 that a right-wing blogger had published the home address of Rep. Steve Driehaus (D-OH) and asked protestors to show up at his house. In addition, Driehaus reportedly received death threats.
17. Brick thrown through window of Witchita County Democrats’ offices. The Kansas City Star reported in March:
Mike Vanderboegh of Pinson, Ala., former leader of the Alabama Constitutional Militia, put out a call on Friday for modern “Sons of Liberty” to break the windows of Democratic Party offices nationwide in opposition to health care reform. Since then, vandals have struck several offices, including the Sedgwick County Democratic Party headquarters in Wichita.
“There’s glass everywhere,” said Lyndsay Stauble, executive director of the Sedgwick County Democratic Party. “A brick took out the whole floor-to-ceiling window and put a gouge in my desk.”
Stauble said the brick, hurled through the window between Friday night and Saturday morning, had “some anti-Obama rhetoric” written on it.
Adam H. Shah is a Deputy Editorial Director at Media Matters for America. He has worked as senior counsel for the Judicial Selection Project at Alliance for Justice.

Michigan Militia plans ‘open carry’ gun tea party to ‘take the stigma out of the word militia.’

Michigan Militia tea partyThis Saturday, on April 10, the Michigan Militia plans to host a tea party “open carry” gun rally. The Militia, which is a successor to the violent anti-government Michigan Militias of the mid-’90s, has come under criticism since the FBI raids of the Hutaree, a Michigan-based Christian militia that had planned to murder police officers. The Michigan Militia cooperated with the FBI to arrest the Hutaree and claimed that although they “had occasional contacts with the Hutaree militia,” they “had never trained with them.” Mike Lackomar, a spokesman for the militia, defended the planned “open carry” rally and again tried to distance himself from the Hutaree:
“This event primarily tries to take the stigma out of the word ‘militia,’ and provide information on what we are and who we are,” Lackomar said. “It lets people meet us and see what we’re all about.” [...] “I want it to be perfectly clear,” Lackomar said. “(The Hutaree) are not us, and we are not them, and we did not agree with their philosophy.”
However, according to their own website, the Michigan Militia boasts of being joined by their “friends” in the Hutaree shortly before leaving their training session to eat fajitas back in 2007. In a photo gallery published by the Michigan Militia in 2008 (now deleted), they posted pictures of the Hutaree with the caption: “Like ghosts through the woods, The Hutaree close on their objective.” The tea parties, anti-government militia groups, and far right elements of the Republican Party are slowly merging. Gun right advocates are planning rallies on the 15th anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing around the country, with even Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli (R) slated to speak at one of the events.


Would you call me crazy if I told you that I think America is more obsessed with Hitler today than it was during WWII?  I have to admit that’s quite an overstatement on my part.
So what if I said, Americans have drawn more Hitler mustaches on protest signs in the last couple years than any other time in history?
We saw a virtual sea of Hitler and nazi references during the Tea Party protests.  Loud angry people.  Screaming and vigorously brandishing signs depicting Obama with a Hitler mustache.
We’re now seeing the same thing in Wisconsin.  Loud angry people.  Screaming and vigorously brandishing signs depicting Scott Walker with a Hitler Mustache.

*That is if the whole thing isn’t part of the recent
Breitbarting attempts that have been made against the credibility of the protesters.
The left called The Tea Party violent thugs when they did it, and now the right is calling the Wisconsin protesters violent thugs when they do it.  The right called The Tea Party patriotic, caring, champions of freedom when they did it, and now the left is calling the Wisconsin protesters patriotic, caring, champions of freedom when they do it.
Why is it always wrong when the other guys do it, and always excusable when our guys do it?
There was, and only will be, one Hitler.  Until someone has supervised a mass genocide project or put several million people to death, drawing a Hitler mustache on their picture just makes you look like a paranoid idiot.
The same goes for references to Stalin, Marx, Mussolini, Lenin, Mao, or any other boogeymen du jour.  Clinging to these types of sensationalist associations doesn’t lend any credibility to any cause.  Taking the easy-out of slapping these labels on your political opponents only makes your stance look factually weak.
I guess we can’t really blame people for getting sucked into this kindergarten level of political discourse.  It’s being pushed by major media and their investors every day.  Presenting things in this type of oversimplified manner is a great way of recruiting anyone and everyone into the game of politics.
Replacing facts with emotional generalizations allows even the least intelligent of Americans to play.  All they need to know is “what is right in their hearts”.  Just link together a string of pre-approved talking points, mix in a genocidal boogeyman or two for good measure, point your finger at the right target, and you’re good to go.
Instant political pundit!
Credibility may not be of much value to the powers that seek to influence our political landscape.  But that doesn’t mean that we as citizens cannot demand it from ourselves.  That doesn’t mean that we can’t hold ourselves accountable.
I believe it is our solemn duty to demand credibility from the political movements that we affiliate ourselves with.  If we do not, then we will be judged according to the actions of our chosen affiliations, and we will be to blame for those judgments made against us.

That’s why I want to say to any liberals and progressives out there, “Enough with the Hitler signs already!”  If your message is so weak that you feel you have to resort to sensationalist boogeyman tactics, then perhaps you need to reconsider your involvement in politics.
Don’t take a just and righteous cause and tarnish it with tactics exhibited by the lowest common denominator.  Demand decency, integrity, and factual accuracy from your base and provide an honorable example to all Americans.

If you want anyone to take you seriously, you need to stick with facts and leave the baseless theatrics and sensationalism to the opposition.
You’re making yourselves (and by association, myself) look like this guy.