By Mark Morford, SF Gate Columnist
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Did anyone punch anyone? Was there any actual blood? I think I might've missed it.Did Pelosi kick John Boehner in the testicles and then run away laughing before a screeching Virginia Foxx grabbed her by the hair, pulled her to the floor and punched her in the kidneys?Did just about everyone on the House floor bitch-slap Bart Stupak -- who should right now vanish of the face of the earth forevermore, you simpering mealworm -- while Rahm Emmanuel head-butted Harry Reid, even as both burned a sneering Newt Gingrich doll in effigy? I might've been dreaming.
Did Obama finally strut in like a prize-fighter, like a Muay Thai boxer, bruised and exhausted after a solid year of this insane, polarizing BS, the viciousness of which even he never imagined? Did he deliver a dazzling barrage of calm, swift kicks to the heads of bitchy Repubs and nervous Dems alike, as everything devolved into a violent, smoke-filled melee of broken glass and shattered dentures, with little Joe Lieberman whimpering in the corner, rocking back and forth, wondering whatever happened to his integrity?
I don't think any of that happened. It sure felt like it happened. Maybe it should have happened. But I guess it didn't.
Behold, with the astonishing passage of flawed-but-incredible health care reform, we have the concomitant, frightening realization that this remains one of the most acidic, bitter, hopelessly divisive times to live in America and care a whit for national politics while maintaining a shred of morality, hope, a progressive soul.
Like millions, I was fairly convinced it simply could not get much worse or more acrimonious than when Dubya ran the nation into the ground, embarrassing and humiliating us planetwide a thousand times over as the rogue idiot pseudo-cowboy laughingstock war-hungry prick of the civilized world. I was wrong. But not in the way I imagined.
As Paul Krugman rightly points out, most Dems in the HCR fight reluctantly took their cues from Obama himself; they were inspired and urged to move from a place of genuinely trying to do what's right, a rather simple moral good for the nation, even at the expense of their own careers, all led by Obama's genuine ideal that basic health care is a national right, not a privilege.
In short, despite all their whining and infighting, the left wasn't pushing HCR because they wanted to stick it to the GOP. They weren't pushing it because they wanted to personally profit from various corporate cronies, though I'm sure some certainly will. They weren't pushing it due to multiple personal agendas. It was an authentic, at least somewhat egalitarian push to advance a basic ideal of the nation. Well, mostly. Which, in politics, is about as good as it gets.
The Republicans, on the other hand, were pure venom. Theirs was a systematic fearmongering, a nonstop bombardment of misguidings and untruths, an acid bath of panic overlaid with a fine sheen of racism and rage. This is turning out to be easily the nastiest, meanest GOP organization in ages, the house that Karl Rove built, a group shaming their own party's once-noble legacy. Even Reagan, who claimed Medicare would destroy the country, would be stunned at this gang's level of savagery.
Common wisdom now holds that while Obama finally succeeded in a truly historic, once-impossible vote, he has failed in his promise to be the uniter president, the community organizer of our liberal dreams, the guy who could somehow mend or at least bridge the hemorrhaging rift, not merely between the two parties, but also the two sides of American culture. This rift is defined hereby as the gulf between people with extant intelligence and subtle understanding of ideas, and the Sarah Palin-grade paranoids who don't quite understand what the hell they're raging about, but nevertheless do so with much clenched passion, fake tears, guns and a whole garage full of stockpiled bullets.
This is, to me, perhaps the saddest outcome of the insane health care fight. Not even Obama, the most intelligent, calm and experienced bringer-together president we could possibly hope for, was able to make a dent in the great wall. In fact, all evidence indicates he's even more polarizing, the absolute reverse of dumb-guy Bush who so violently repelled the intelligent and the informed. Obama is doing the opposite: the paranoids are so scared by the guy's untouchable force field of smarts and self-assurance, they're coagulating into little clusters, foamy little pools of resistance and anti-gummint hate.
Verily, health care reform will go down in history for many things -- Catholic nuns kicking ass, Ted Kennedy not having to roll in his grave, Democrats actually vaguely unifying -- but few are as amusing as the creation of the silliest political movement in recent American history, the Tea Party, a group barely cognizant of what it even stands for, with zero grasp of the history it's named after, who nevertheless will doubtlessly grab every tax benefit, housing subsidy, COBRA extension, Restoration Act moneys and (now) health care benefit that evil socialist Obama hands to them and their sniveling home states, even as they spit tobacco juice in his face. Adorable.
Perhaps the saddest idea of all, however, is the general lament I've heard repeated countless times on the left, this sense that if Obama can't do it, if this astonishingly calm and assured, rock solid, deeply reasonable president can't bridge the divide or at least hack through some of that barbed wire, we are, if not completely doomed, then certainly stuck deep in a sociocultural abyss no one has a clue how to navigate.
Eventually, something will have to give. Much like Wal-Mart pretending to care about going "green" because it realizes it can make/save lots of money, or Exxon pretending it gives a damn about the environment because it's a good PR move, perhaps the only way to force a change upon modern politicians it is to somehow incentivize it, to make it in both parties' best interests to shut the hell up and work together, lest we corral all of them into the street with pitchforks and fire, and run them off a cliff.I have no idea how this can be done, what magic levers might be pulled or what miraculous tactical maneuver from Obama could possibly make both sides come to terms with the hateful chasm separating them -- and by extension, us. The environment? Education? High-fructose corn syrup? Wall Street? Colonizing deep space? No one knows.
One thing do we know for sure: As stunned, bedazzled and burned by the HCR fight as Americans feel right now, that's nothing compared to how we would respond when presented with some dramatic, exciting step forward that both parties were able to agree upon via passionate, articulate, thoughtful discussion and debate. True compassion, honesty, and heart? In thiscongress? Now that's impossible.
Comments
I thought the cartoon was
To be really funny you need to make humorous points that weren't first promulgated by the "other side".
Keep trying, you are almost there.
Your pov is perfect.
This was one of your best
I love the cartoon; Keep up
He wouldn't have been let
faithful PAYING zealots,
and the Canadians were so
Coulter is offensive to all
Not as offensive as
The justice is completely
Go ahead and name one single
I think that this cartoon is
You people ought to be
Wow..I don't understand the
And which side of the
Plain and simple? Both
And why, in the world, do people get so upset over talkshow and radio hosts; they are the verbal equivalent of wrestling. It's a gun for hire concept that attracts listeners and makes lots and lots of money. Most of these 'professionals' would advocate eating rocks and painting yourself purple if it increased their drive time audience.
Of course, my glass house has cracks in it! So does yours. There really ain't no California; not in politics, not in life.
All that I tried to suggest is that we stop the vicious attacks, on all fronts; why can't we just have a bit of harmless fun instead of vilifying anyone who holds an opposing view. A glass of wine, maybe even (God forbid!) a cigarette, point, counterpoint and everyone leaves still liking and respecting each other. I think, I'm not sure, but I think it's called 'civilization.'
Wake up, America! Not only
So, you're Catholic? Then,
Baby killing is wrong. I
You do not understand fetal
Its wrong for killing
I am a progressive that has
A fetus is not a baby.
> A fetus is not a baby. Of
Love the fetus and hate the
Firstly, I've never railed
Oh, OK, let's kill it then.
Can't kill something that
Thats what the Germans used
And why bother making a
I don't always agree with
But it has never been a
Medically, they're about the
So how many crack addicted,
Nothing like a personal
Brilliant! Keep up the
Controversy?
http://voodoomanager.com/
These same people screamed
This is a hilarious cartoon!
Thank you, Mark! Don't mind
I find it chilling that the
*Whistle* Looks like the NPR
Reading these comments make
I find it funny. No I really
Mr. Goldberg needs to read
do tea baggers also wet the
I believe that Hitler and
Thank you --- I now feel
When members of a movement
I think your observations
Rock on. Second paragraph, I
Mark -- Bravo for meeting
I'm a reformed liberal, and
I am not a liberal but a
way to walk the walk LOL
I thought the idea behind health care reform was to save money make sure more people have access to health care.
Was Jim Adkisson friendly
Was Ralph Nicoletti friendly on election night when he learned Obama won, went on a rampage against blacks. The idiot mistook an anglo wearing a hoodie for a black man and rammed him with his car. The victim was in a coma for 45 days and has severe brain damage.
Well, this is a "sin of the
get real. you state "If you
I doubt if what you are
Funny, I don't recall that.
In the context of GWB and
You are so right, the way
Maybe it would help if you
Calling themselves National
Maybe what he should do is
Keep it up Mark, you are a
Mark, you really think
Or maybe your ridicule just wasn't enough to get through my thick cromagnon skull! Keep trying. I'm sure a few more insults will cure my stupidity.
I doubt anything could cure
Darn you have in just a
Only a fool would believe
An organization is merely
Most excellent - I saw this
This is great satire! Thanks
Thanks for finally putting
Top conservatives are afraid they will lose their control of people who don't realize they keep voting against their own interest.
Now if we could just get
I would like to teabag Sarah
Careful, I bet she bites
That's the only way that
Does Sarah have the proper
ummm... I don't care. I just
Bravo! Bravo! Brilliant!
Thank you. It's difficult
Keep up the good work and
Well said. They realize
Back when I was younger, Tea
Can you please capture the
How about the teabagger with
"I could say you're
"Could be your overactive imagination - are you seeing black helicopters also?"
He's right,I have never met
What, exactly, do you think
a tea bagger is no different
I think you're all missing
"it was patriotic to diss
GREAT video!!! America
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=662R2awSwPQ&feature=related
Wow. What a complete waste
I was very critical of Bush
75% of the country is with
Using their own terminology
Your cartoons are brilliant!
I love how the baggers can
The wing nuts love free
omments
love your stuff, here's a
keep up the excellent work.
But it was hilarious! And,
Keep up the good fight.
GO MARK GO! We already knew
I'm at work, but will look
Before today, I had no idea
My experience as well. My
Keep up the good work--I
All you issue voters should
So you're a wishy-washy
I've admired your work for a
Congratulations on doing
You're the best animated
Oh the irony ... it burns,
Ms. NPR Ombudsman Thank you
Dear talentless liberal
Dude ... you guys made up
Anonymity is such a nice,
I'm not surprised you chose
Lars you a one tough sob.
We LOVE you Mark! Keep up
Mark--very funny stuff, and
Yours is one of the keenest
Mr Fiore, I truly enjoy your
Don't let the American
Ya call 'em like ya see 'em!
Anyone who stirs up the
Thank you. Great piece of
you're an excellent
Brilliant. And so true - I
Don't kill Mark, his brain
Mark, spiffy cartoon! I was
Some of the same people that
Great work Mark... Keep'em
Gawd! Did O'Reilly even
Thank you Mark! Keep up the
"Muslim extremist, meet Tea
Just thought I'd post the
Yes, because the left has a
If you do a little searching
provide links or it didn't
Show, don't tell!
Mark, keep up the good
Good job. Now if only our
The coverage did originate
Congratulations! You're
Considering you compare your
!!!!!!!!! I LOVE YOUR
Love your positive attitude
Your next cartoon should
Violent Dominionists and
Mark - you prove that the
Thanks for fighting the good
I wonder if the Rosetta
O nozzzzzzz! You exposed the
Enjoyed the cartoon, please
Agree with the moose hunting
Keep it up Mark! I've seen
Love you work! Keep up the
I have to laugh - I've been
The outrage is not over the
As has already been noted,
Teabaggers are calling Obama
I can't believe nobody has
It is not just that his
Um, I love you.
The VA system is truly run
I can't believe nobody has
Thank you Mark, True
Stay safe Mark. Great
The teabag wackanutcases
Mark: When I was receiving
Anne Rand? Is that Ayn's
It's really Astounding (with
Yes and yes.
KTLK's Johnny Angel Wendell
Make some Repub media
What a tempest in a
Looks like O'Really! is
Mark, congratulations,
I have the same reaction to
Oh ... you're Catholic ...
I just stood up for this
Mark, I would be scared if I
You're going to serve time
Absolutely - discussion is
What a great response Mark!
A progressive-leaning, child
And yet you can't even spell
Excuse me, Ayn Rand....it
Well typed, Mark. Keep up
Why do you bring Barney
Great letter, Mark. Keep up